Introduction: "That's stupid" This past summer I went to a Cleveland Guardians baseball game with some college friends. We had all been students at Case Western Reserve University 20-odd years ago; some, like me, still live in the area, others now live elsewhere. While chatting with one of my old friends, he mentioned memories of going jogging around Horseshoe Lake (located a little more than a mile from where I now live in Cleveland Heights). Horseshoe Lake, October 2016 "It's not a lake anymore," I told him. He was surprised, and I explained how the (very old) dam that created the lake had had problems, and it had been decided to remove the dam and restore the brook through where the lake had sat. (Note: I didn't know at the time that the "restore the brook" concept was misleading. We'll get to that later. Anyway...) "That's stupid," he said. I think this moment was instructive when we consider the ongoing debate ...
Weird but true: if NEORSD "brings back the brook," you won't be able to take a walk next to the brook
I love going for walks alongside Doan Brook. The ravine downstream of Lower Shaker Lake is one of my favorite places in the world, and honestly, I've easily spent more time there than I have at the lakes. We're so lucky to have a place like that where you can feel like you're out in wild nature even though you're still in the middle of a city. Here are some pictures I've taken on walks in the ravine: It's such a magical place and I just love it so much. The ravine isn't the only place to go for a nice walk by Doan Brook. The Nature Center, of course, also provides that opportunity. There are also other lesser-known spots such as the valley downstream of the dam at Horseshoe Lake (note that in the currently existing park, there's a trail next to the brook): And the section of the brook west of Lee Road, between the two lakes, is another really nice spot: As the section of brook perhaps least altered by humans, this shows roughly what the brook would...